On the stage of “America’s Got Talent,” Sam Cieri became the center of attention, especially among the ladies in the audience, with his enchanting vocal performance. This heartthrob from New Jersey had everyone captivated not just with his looks but with his exceptional musical talent. During his interaction with the judges, his charm was undeniable, but it was his singing that truly stole the show.

Accompanied by the gentle keys of a piano, Cieri showcased a voice that was not only technically proficient but also uniquely his own. His performance was a showcase of his individuality as a singer, bringing a distinct, smoky quality to his vocals that left a lasting impression.

Demonstrating his talents as a songwriter as well, Cieri chose to perform an original piece titled “What Makes You Sad” from his indie band, Nicotine Dolls, highlighting his versatility and creativity as an artist.

The judges had mixed reactions, with Heidi Klum and Sofía Vergara immediately standing to applaud Cieri’s performance, visibly impressed by his talent. Simon Cowell, though remaining seated, acknowledged Cieri’s performance with a gesture of approval. Klum couldn’t hide her admiration, saying, “I mean, if Rod Stewart and John Mayer had a baby.”

Cieri responded with a witty remark, further endearing him to the audience and judges alike, “They’re my parents.” Klum then gushed, “You have a very, very special voice.”

Vergara openly expressed her admiration for Cieri’s unique appeal, describing him as different, sexy, and perfectly timed for his moment to shine. Cowell’s feedback pointed to the authenticity and honesty in Cieri’s performance, suggesting a depth and dual nature to his talent that resonated with the panel and audience.

Cowell said “You know what’s great Sam, is that it was really authentic. You were very honest with us as well… It was like you’d swallowed a great singer because the way you talk is like there’s somebody else in you.”