American Idol Shakes Things Up: Carrie Underwood Replaces Katy Perry—Fans Divided!

American Idol is entering a new era, and the changes are already sparking heated reactions among viewers. With Katy Perry stepping away from the judges’ table, country music superstar Carrie Underwood has stepped in, making history as the first former winner to return as a judge.

Underwood, who won Season 4 in 2005, joins Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan on the panel for Season 23, which premiered on March 9. While some fans are thrilled to see an Idol champion take on this new role, others are struggling to adjust to the absence of Perry, who had been a judge since the show’s revival on ABC in 2018.

Carrie Underwood’s Debut Draws Strong Opinions

Underwood’s first night as a judge was emotional. The Cry Pretty singer, who knows firsthand what it’s like to stand nervously before a panel, showed deep compassion for contestants. Many fans praised her for bringing authenticity and heartfelt feedback to the show.

“I love that Carrie understands what these singers are going through,” one fan wrote on social media. “She’s been in their shoes.”

Another added, “Wait, American Idol traded Katy Perry for Carrie Underwood? Unacceptable.”

However, not all Idol viewers are embracing the change. Social media was flooded with mixed reactions, with many expressing how much they miss Perry.

“Oh, Carrie Underwood, you’re no Katy Perry,” one person tweeted. Another added, “Wait, American Idol traded Katy Perry for Carrie Underwood? Unacceptable.”

At the same time, Underwood is already winning over new supporters. Some viewers feel that her experience as a contestant gives her an edge.

“Carrie Underwood taking the place of Katy Perry, who failed to recognize Jack Blocker’s talent last year—now that’s an upgrade,” one fan posted.

Why Did Katy Perry Leave?

Perry’s exit was not fueled by controversy or behind-the-scenes drama. The pop icon made it clear that she simply wanted to focus on her music and explore new opportunities.

“I feel like I need to go out and feel that pulse to my own beat,” Perry said during an interview on Jimmy Kimmel Live!. “I love the show so much, but I wanna go and see the world and maybe bring new music.”

Her departure marks the end of an era for Idol, as she was one of the show’s most outspoken and entertaining judges.

What’s Next for American Idol?

With Underwood now at the table, American Idol is embracing a fresh perspective. As a country superstar and one of the most successful artists to emerge from the show, her presence brings a unique dynamic.

Whether fans will fully embrace her remains to be seen, but one thing is certain—Season 23 will be unlike any other.