SHOCKING: Caitlin Clark is NOT the Best Point Guard According to WNBA Media—Then Who Is?
The debate over who holds the title of the best point guard in the WNBA has taken a surprising turn, and not in Caitlin Clark’s favor. Despite her record-breaking rookie season and undeniable impact on the league, WNBA media members are pushing back, suggesting that Chelsea Gray is still the best at her position. The statement, coming from WNBA reporter Natalie Esquire, has sent shockwaves through the fan base and reignited the discussion about media bias, statistics, and what truly defines greatness.
According to Esquire, Chelsea Gray’s standing as the league’s top point guard has not changed, even after an injury-riddled season. “Chelsea Gray is the best point guard in the WNBA. That hasn’t changed because she had a down year returning from injury. The disrespect on her name is ridiculous,” she wrote. The claim immediately sparked backlash, with fans questioning whether this was based on factual analysis or simply a case of favoritism.
Looking at the numbers, Caitlin Clark’s dominance is clear. In her rookie season, she averaged 19.2 points, 8.4 assists, and 5.7 rebounds per game—statistically outpacing every version of Chelsea Gray’s career. Gray, even at her best, has never reached those numbers in points or assists. During her 2022 championship season with the Las Vegas Aces, Gray put up 15.3 points and 7.3 assists per game, respectable but still behind what Clark has achieved in just one season. Even in her best years, Gray’s numbers never surpassed Clark’s in any significant category.
The push to anoint Chelsea Gray as the best point guard despite these numbers has led many to question whether WNBA media members are actively trying to suppress Caitlin Clark’s rise. Clark has already faced relentless scrutiny since entering the league, with accusations of stat-padding, complaints about the attention she receives, and an overall resistance to acknowledging the generational talent she brings to the game. Seven months ago, Esquire was among those who accused Clark of chasing records and playing selfishly, implying that her impressive stats were more about personal milestones than team success. Now, with a chance to solidify her status as the league’s top point guard, media narratives are shifting again to prop up a different player.
The timing of this argument is interesting. Chelsea Gray recently had a standout performance in the Unrivaled League, dropping 26 points in a win and reminding fans of the impact she can have when fully healthy. While no one denies that Gray is an elite player, the suggestion that she is still ahead of Clark, despite a statistical gap, is a hard sell. If this debate were purely about longevity and legacy, then sure, Gray’s championships and experience would weigh heavily in her favor. But if the discussion is about who is playing the best basketball right now, the numbers—and the eye test—favor Clark.
Esquire’s take has not gone unchallenged. Fans and analysts have been quick to pull up receipts, comparing Clark’s rookie season to not just Gray, but the league’s best guards over the past decade. Clark is putting up numbers that few, if any, have reached this early in their careers, making the idea that she isn’t at least in the conversation for best point guard laughable. And yet, the resistance continues.
The reluctance to acknowledge Clark’s impact goes beyond just one reporter’s opinion. There has been a consistent effort in certain corners of the WNBA media to downplay her accomplishments. While her peers recognize her talent, and fans pack arenas to see her play, some members of the media seem determined to shift the focus elsewhere. Whether it’s nitpicking her game, exaggerating her mistakes, or constantly questioning whether she “deserves” the attention she gets, it’s clear that Clark is held to a different standard.
The real question is why. Is it resentment toward the attention she has brought to the league? Is it an attempt to uphold the old guard of WNBA stars and push back against the idea that a rookie could immediately take the league by storm? Or is it simply media bias at play, where personal preferences and existing narratives matter more than facts?
While the debate rages on, Caitlin Clark is letting her game speak for itself. She isn’t arguing for recognition, demanding praise, or engaging in these media narratives—she’s simply playing basketball at an elite level. Whether the WNBA media acknowledges it or not, fans see what’s happening. Clark is redefining what it means to be a point guard in this league, bringing a combination of scoring, playmaking, and leadership that few can match.
As the 2025 season approaches, this conversation isn’t going away. With Chelsea Gray back at full strength and Clark looking to build on her historic rookie season, the battle for the title of best point guard will play out on the court. And while media narratives can be shaped and opinions can be spun, the numbers, the performances, and the impact will ultimately tell the real story.
Who do you think is the best point guard in the WNBA? Is Chelsea Gray still at the top, or has Caitlin Clark already taken that crown? Let us know your thoughts.
