The relationship between Indiana Fever star NaLyssa Smith and the franchise has been a complex, tension-filled saga that has kept fans and analysts intrigued all season. What began as a promising partnership soon became a dramatic stand-off, primarily between Smith and former Fever head coach Christie Sides. This strained dynamic has played out publicly and privately, with Smith’s family, particularly her brother, often weighing in online with “likes” on tweets critical of Sides.

From the start, Smith’s frustrations with her role under Sides’ leadership were evident, as she openly engaged with online criticism of the coach. Then, as the Fever’s season came to an end without a playoff berth, Smith promptly removed any mention of the Indiana Fever from her social media bios, signaling a potential departure. But when Christie Sides was relieved of her duties, Smith swiftly restored “Indiana Fever” to her bio, suggesting a renewed openness to staying with the team under different management.

Smith’s brother also became vocal in support of the change, hinting at the positive effect that new head coach Stephanie White could have on Smith’s future with the Fever. White, known for her strategic expertise and ability to nurture player potential, is seen as the ideal coach to help Smith reach her full potential and possibly even earn the Most Improved Player award. According to sources close to the team, White’s leadership style may align better with Smith’s strengths, especially if White positions her in a way that maximizes her interior scoring and rebounding abilities rather than relying on outside shooting.

With Sides’ departure and White’s arrival, the Fever must now consider whether to keep or trade Smith. Despite the tensions, Smith has shown flashes of brilliance on the court, averaging a double-double in the 2023 season and nearly earning an All-Star spot. The Fever front office must weigh her potential impact against the value she could bring in a trade, especially given her tradeable status as a restricted free agent. Some insiders argue that Smith’s strong play could make her a valuable trade asset next season, potentially fetching a top draft pick or another rising star.

Another twist to the story is the Fever’s possible interest in top prospects like Civia Bar or Citen Wan, both of whom are expected to be high picks in the upcoming draft. Retaining Smith might secure their leverage for a mid-season trade or even make her an attractive package for a first-round pick if Indiana targets these players. Furthermore, there is interest from other teams in Smith, particularly the Golden State Valkyries, who could swoop in if she were left unprotected.

However, Smith’s recent social media activity and re-engagement with the Fever suggest that she might be willing to give the franchise another shot under White’s leadership. White’s reputation for supporting player growth has made some think that Smith could finally be put in the right role—a more aggressive, cut-oriented position that capitalizes on her strengths in transition and defense. In past games, Smith showed significant potential, particularly in her dominant performance against Chicago, where her energy and scoring ability were on full display.

Adding to the intrigue, Smith’s partner, DiJonai Carrington, has a longstanding feud with the Fever, which has only added fuel to the tension surrounding Smith’s status on the team. Carrington’s public remarks have often hinted at underlying frustrations with the franchise, and many speculate that her influence may impact Smith’s decision-making.

While the Fever contemplate their next steps, Smith’s future remains uncertain. If the Fever choose to keep her, they’ll likely do so with the hope of developing her further under White’s guidance. Alternatively, if they see an opportunity to acquire significant assets in exchange, they may decide it’s best to move on.

This offseason will be a critical moment for Indiana as they work to balance their roster and make the moves necessary to reshape the team. For now, fans will be closely watching the Fever’s strategy and Smith’s response as the team prepares for a new chapter under Stephanie White’s leadership.

4o