The NFL legend may be the greatest quarterback to ever lace up a pair of cleats, but Tom Brady’sbroadcasting career got off to a shaky start this past Sunday, leaving fans scratching their heads. Brady, who signed a jaw-dropping 10-year, $375 million deal with FOX to be their lead NFL analyst, made his highly anticipated debut during the Browns-Cowboys matchup. But judging by the audience’s reactions, it wasn’t exactly a touchdown performance.

In what was supposed to be the next great chapter in his post-football career, Brady’s nerves seemed to get the best of him. Fans were quick to notice that the seven-time Super Bowl champ didn’t sound as confident in the booth as he did in the huddle. Social media lit up with viewers commenting on how uncomfortable he appeared.

“Did anyone actually hear Tom speak before handing him $300 million? He sounds like he’s still warming up,” one fan sarcastically tweeted. It wasn’t the smooth, charismatic Brady they were expecting, but instead, someone who might need a bit more time to adjust to his new role.

For a man who’s conquered almost everything on the football field, many were surprised by the apparent lack of excitement in his voice. “Tom Brady sounds about as hyped as someone waiting at the DMV,” quipped another fan. Ouch. Fans clearly want more energy from the GOAT in his new gig, and they’re not holding back.

Even Scott Hanson, the face of NFL RedZone, joined the chorus of critics. While not directly attacking Brady, Hanson hinted that the broadcast could’ve used a little more flair. “It’s just not what we expected from someone of Brady’s caliber,” Hanson said, subtly throwing shade at the former QB.

Brady’s first broadcast leaves fans and FOX execs watching closely

Brady’s critics weren’t just focused on his lack of energy, though. Some pointed out that he sounded genuinely nervous during his first foray into live sports commentary. “I don’t know if Tom Brady will end up being a bad broadcaster, but it’s jarring how nervous he sounds today,” another fan remarked on X, summing up the consensus.

Tom Brady shares funny reaction to Belichick joining Instagram

Fans weren’t the only ones who noticed the tension in Brady’s voice. According to sources, FOX executives are taking the feedback seriously but believe it’s only a matter of time before the superstar finds his groove. After all, it’s Brady’s first major step into this new arena-everyone’s allowed a little room to grow, right?

Still, it wasn’t all bad for Brady on Sunday. Some fans came to his defense, reminding the haters that it was only his debut and he’s likely to improve with time. “Cut the guy some slack,” one supportive viewer wrote. “It’s his first day on the job, and we all know what happens when Brady gets comfortable-he wins.”

With a lucrative contract on the line and the pressure to deliver as high as ever, it’s safe to say all eyes will be on Brady in the weeks to come. Will he bounce back like he always has on the field, or will broadcasting prove to be the one challenge that gets the best of him?

For now, Tom Brady’s transition from the gridiron to the booth is still a work in progress. But he’s the GOAT, he’ll figure it out.